Your roof is the part of your house you look at least and pay the most to fix. Hiring the wrong roofer costs money, and it can cost you months of leaks and phone calls.
This guide covers what to check this fall, how to tell a repair from a full replacement, why asphalt shingles and winter don’t mix well, and the questions to ask any Calgary roofing contractor before you sign.
Before the snow: what to check this fall
Calgary weather turns fast. Ten minutes now can save you a leak in January.
- Missing, lifted or cracked shingles. Look from the ground after a windy day. Binoculars help. Stay off the roof: cold shingles crack under your feet.
- Eavestroughs and downspouts. Clear the leaves. Blocked eavestroughs make ice dams worse.
- Flashing, vents, chimneys and skylights. Many leaks start where something goes through the roof, not in the middle of the shingles.
- Your attic. Frost on the nails or the underside of the roof, damp insulation, or a musty smell all point to a ventilation or air-leak problem. Read more about attic rain.
- Hail damage from this summer. Damage that is hard to see from the ground can still leak later. A written inspection with photos also helps if you make an insurance claim. Our Calgary hail damage guide explains what to look for.

Not sure what you’re looking at? A roof inspection before freeze-up is cheaper than a repair in February.
Repair or replacement? A good roofer will tell you the truth
Not every leak means a new roof. Plenty of roof problems are small, local and quick to fix. If a roofer recommends a full replacement for every call, ask why.
A repair is often enough when:
- The damage is in one area: a few shingles, a damaged vent, or a failed flashing or skylight seal.
- The rest of the roof is in good shape: shingles lying flat, granules intact, no widespread curling.
- The leak has a clear cause that can be fixed.

Replacement makes sense when:
- Shingles are curling, cracking or losing granules across whole slopes.
- Leaks keep coming back in different places.
- Hail or wind has damaged most of the roof.
- The roof deck underneath is soft or rotted.
- The roof is at the end of its life. See how long a roof should last in Calgary.
Our repair or replacement guide goes through this in more detail.
How to avoid being oversold
- Ask the roofer to show you photos of the problem and point out exactly where it is.
- Ask for the repair price and the replacement price in writing.
- Ask what happens if you wait a year. A real answer is specific. A pressure answer is “it could fail any day.”
- If the answer is “replace it” and you haven’t seen the evidence, get a second opinion.
Winter and asphalt shingles: why we usually wait
Short answer: it can be done, but it isn’t what we would choose for your roof.
Most asphalt shingles are held down by a strip of sealant that is activated by heat. According to the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA), sealing time depends on the slope, the direction the roof faces and how much sun it gets. In cold weather that bond can be slow to form or may not form at all until warmer weather returns. Manufacturers generally recommend that shingles go on at about 4°C (40°F) and rising, and each brand sets its own limit.
What that means on a Calgary roof in winter:
- Unsealed shingles can lift in the wind. A chinook can get under shingles that haven’t bonded yet.
- Cold shingles are stiff. They can crack when they are bent over ridges, hips and valleys.
- Frost and ice make the work unsafe and make it harder to lay shingles flat.
- Hand-sealing is a last resort. Crews can put roofing cement under every shingle by hand. It takes more time and costs more, and we don’t normally recommend it. We would only consider it when a repair truly can’t hold your roof until spring.
Here is how we handle it. In winter we focus on the repairs that protect your home right now, and we install flat roofs all winter. For a full shingle replacement, we recommend waiting for better weather. See our winter roofing page and our guide to the best season for a roof replacement in Calgary.
If a roofer is keen to do a full shingle replacement in January and doesn’t mention cold-weather sealing, ask how they will make sure the shingles seal, and whether hand-sealing is in the price.
Questions to ask any Calgary roofing contractor before you hire

1. Do they have a real Calgary address?
Search the company on Google Maps. A verified Google Business Profile with a local address, reviews and photos is a good sign. A company with only a phone number is harder to find when something goes wrong a year later.
2. Do they work on your type of roof?
Asphalt shingles, cedar shakes, flat roofs and tile are different trades. Ask what share of their work is your roof type, and ask for examples of recent similar jobs.
3. Will they give you a written quote?
Get at least three, and compare what is in them, not just the total. A good written quote says:
- what work will be done
- which materials will be used
- the timeline and when payment is due
- what warranty comes with the job
Our roof replacement cost guide explains what drives the price. The cheapest quote is not always the best one. Ask why the lowest quote is lowest. Be cautious of anyone who wants a large deposit before materials are even ordered.
4. What do past customers say?
Read reviews on more than one site. Look for patterns, and for how the company handles problems, not just the star rating. You can read ours on the W4SR reviews page.
5. Are they licensed, insured and covered by WCB?
The Government of Alberta’s advice on hiring a contractor is to check three things before work starts:
- A City of Calgary business licence. Ask to see a copy.
- Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB) coverage. Ask for the WCB number.
- A certificate of insurance. Ask to see a current one.
Roofing is dangerous work. Without proper coverage, an injury or damage on your property can become your problem.
6. What warranty do they offer?
There are two kinds, and you want both in writing:
- Workmanship warranty. From the roofer, for installation errors.
- Manufacturer warranty. From the maker, for material defects.
Ask how long each lasts, whether it transfers if you sell the house, and what voids it.
7. Will they tell you when a repair is enough?
This one is the real test. Ask: “Do I need a new roof, or can this be fixed?” A roofer who can show you the problem and give you both prices is one you can trust with the bigger job.
Red flags
- Someone knocks on your door after a storm saying they were “in the neighbourhood.” See how to protect yourself from roofing scams.
- You are pressured to sign today.
- There is no written contract.
- They can’t show proof of insurance or WCB coverage.
- They recommend a full replacement without going on the roof or showing you photos.
- They ask for full payment up front.
Already have a roof that looks wrong? See what a bad roof installation looks like.
Not sure if you need a repair or a replacement?
Whalleys Four Seasons Roofing is a family-run Calgary roofing company with decades of experience. We work on asphalt shingle, cedar shake and flat roofs, and we do repairs, inspections and replacements for homes and commercial buildings. If a repair is enough, we’ll tell you.
Call us at (403) 288-8819 or request a free quote.
Frequently asked questions
How can I find a good roofer in Calgary?
Check three things before you compare prices: a City of Calgary business licence, WCB coverage and a current certificate of insurance. Then read reviews on more than one site and get at least three written quotes. The questions above walk through each step.
How much does a new roof cost in Calgary?
It depends on the size and pitch of the roof, the material, and what is under the old shingles. A written quote after an inspection is the only reliable number. Our roof replacement cost guide explains what moves the price.
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a roof?
A repair costs less up front when the damage is in one area and the rest of the roof is sound. If the roof is near the end of its life or the problems are widespread, repeated repairs add up, and replacement is usually the better value. See our repair or replacement guide.
What time of year should I replace a roof?
Most shingle replacements are done in milder weather, when the sealant strips can bond. Our guide to the best season for a roof replacement in Calgary covers the trade-offs.
Can you replace a roof in winter?
Flat roofs, yes. Asphalt shingle roofs can be installed in cold weather, but the sealant strips may not bond until it warms up. Manufacturers generally recommend about 4°C (40°F) and rising, and each brand sets its own limit. Hand-sealing costs more and we don’t normally recommend it, so we suggest repairing now and replacing when the weather is better. See our winter roofing page.
How do I know if I need a roof repair or a replacement?
A repair is usually enough for damage in one area on a roof that is otherwise in good shape. Replacement makes sense when the problems are widespread, keep coming back, or the roof is near the end of its life.
Should I choose the cheapest roofing quote?
No. Compare what each quote includes, ask why the lowest is lowest, and check licensing, WCB coverage, insurance and warranty before you decide.


